In The Blood by Scott Miller

[katekintailbc]

In The Blood
by Scott Miller
http://www.bookcrossing.com/journal/4929670/

I wanted to love this book, and I didn't. I woke up on the morning of my own personal Do Nothing But Read Day and decided that it had been sitting beside my bed for almost 3 years untouched. I read it straight through in a few hours, and I didn't even cry at the ending. That's not a particularly great sign, considering everything makes me cry.

The style was definitely tell instead of show and the single flashback (I ADORE vampire flashbacks) that tried to show turned out to be sudden, jarring, and disruptive instead.

The thing that I disliked the most was the character inconsistency. Zack is a vampire who does his best to blend in with humanity and pretend not to be a vampire. But then he goes and just confesses to random people at a party that he's a vampire (he does so because he doesn't expect them to believe him, but still). He absolutely REFUSES to turn someone into a vampire. He will NOT cross that line. But then he goes off with a woman he's just met (even though he's in a serious relationship with that woman's cousin's friend) and ends up turning her because she won't make love to him otherwise (even though he can get sex anywhere and she's nothing special). Makes no sense. He refuses to turn his lover, who is a great person, but he will turn this random person for no real reason. Then there's the drinking of blood. He'll occasionally drink animals (which aren't filling at all) because he doesn't morally like to drink humans. The humans he has to drink are carefully chosen as homeless or members of society who won't be missed. But then he goes and drinks his boyfriend's friend, the man who saved his life at the beginning of the book, because he acts without thinking. These characters think WAY too much and 95% of the book is dialogue, and yet he goes and (off camera, because that's where all the action takes place) kills this important guy, even though he doesn't kill for fun (he claims it's because he thought the guy gave his lover AIDS, and he claims not to know that the guy rescued him, but a few paragraphs before he was aware of that fact). Don't even get me started on Zack's morality/rule-breaking or lack thereof. And, worst of all, you've got Adam, a mortal doctor, who spends the whole book saying he will fight hard for a cure for AIDS, doing all he can to save strangers, friends, and himself. But then it's suddenly revealed at the end that he's Catholic, believes in God, and has always thought that if it's a sick person's time to die that's all right because that's the way God wants it. That makes NO sense to me. I can forgive bad writing and lack of plot if the characters are good... but so many inconsistencies and confusing motivations ruined this story completely for me. I never got a good feel for any of the characters, apart from the one-dimensional ones.

Worst of all, the points of view jumped around constantly. There were only a small number of characters in this book and it would have made more sense to pick one of the main characters and stick with him or even alternate between the two leads. Instead, you've got points of view changing from paragraph to paragraph. At one point, you're with Adam as he makes a phone call, and when the phone call is over, you're with Chaz and Danny, who he'd been on the phone with. This makes things like the angst about revealing that Zack is a vampire lose all emotional impact. And though it lets us explore the thoughts of all the different characters, even secondary ones, the power of the narrative is divided. All that jumping around might have something to do with the inconsistency, as well. Hard to keep everyone straight when you're literally jumping around inside everyone's heads.

All that being said, I enjoyed the basic concept. Blood-related diseases and vampirism seem like the perfect match for a dramatic story involving morality and desire. The emotions behind the story are great, as were many of the morality points brought up. The story sped through it all, though, and I barely felt anything at all for the last chapter, which should have been amazingly powerful (I sobbed my heart out at the end of Forever Knight, which came to a somewhat similar end).

I'm glad I read it, because of the subject matter, but it didn't change my world.